Bunpo Dojo

Difference between 〜ている and 〜てある (resulting state)

Both describe a state you can see in front of you, such as “the window is open.” The difference is whether the sentence hints that someone did it.

An intransitive verb + ている just describes the state as it is. A transitive verb + てある tells you that someone did it on purpose, often to prepare for something.

Vています(結果の状態) N4

Describing a state: intransitive verb + ている.

Use it when:

  • Intransitive verb (開く, 閉まる, つく, 壊れる…) + ている
  • It only says “it is in this state,” with no interest in who did it or whether it was on purpose
  • The thing takes が: ドアが開いています
  1. The light is on.
  2. This cup is broken.

Vてあります N4

Someone did it on purpose in advance: transitive verb + てある.

Use it when:

  • Transitive verb (開ける, 閉める, つける, 置く, 書く…) + てある
  • It hints that someone did it for a purpose, often to prepare
  • The object usually changes from を to が: 窓が開けてあります
  1. Tea has been prepared in the meeting room.
  2. A name is written on the whiteboard.

Same situation, different meaning

The window is open (just a description).
The window has been opened (someone opened it on purpose, for example to let in air).

The same scene. てある adds the information “someone did it, with a reason.”

The air conditioner is on.
The air conditioner has been turned on (so that the room is cool when the guests arrive).

When you want to say that someone thoughtfully prepared something, use てある.

Common mistakes

  • Wrongドアが開けています。

    Rightドアが開いています。

    開ける is a transitive verb. To describe the state, use the intransitive verb 開いている (or 開けてある if you mean someone opened it in advance).

  • Wrong窓が壊してあります。

    Right窓が壊れています。

    A broken window is usually not prepared on purpose, so use the intransitive verb 壊れる + ている.

  • Wrongケーキが冷蔵庫に入れています。

    Rightケーキが冷蔵庫に入れてあります。

    入れる is a transitive verb. To describe a cake that has been put in the refrigerator for later → てある.

Ask yourself before choosing

  1. Is the verb intransitive (開く, つく, 壊れる) or transitive (開ける, つける, 壊す)? Intransitive → ている, transitive → てある.
  2. Do you want to say “someone did it on purpose in advance”? If so → てある.
  3. With てある, remember to change を to が.

Practice

You enter a meeting room and see that the documents have been set out on the table. What do you say?
  1. 机の上に資料が並んであります。
  2. 机の上に資料が並べてあります。
  3. 机の上に資料が並べています。
  4. 机の上に資料を並びています。
Show the answer and explanation
机の上に資料が並べてあります。
Someone set them out on purpose → transitive verb 並べる + てある.
You see a wallet that someone dropped on the ground: 「あ、財布が__よ。」
  1. 落としてあります
  2. 落ちています
  3. 落ちてあります
  4. 落としています
Show the answer and explanation
落ちています
The wallet did not fall on purpose → intransitive verb 落ちる + ている.

Where this page comes from

The patterns are selected and graded to match the JLPT N5〜N1 range. The explanations and example sentences are written by Bunpo Dojo and are not copied from any textbook. If you find a mistake, please write to juxingdaochang@foxmail.com.