Bunpo Dojo

Difference between たことがある and ることがある

Only た and る differ, but the meanings are completely different: たことがある is an experience (have done …), and ることがある is something that happens now and then (sometimes …).

Look at the adverb that goes with it: 一度, 前に, 子どものころ → experience; ときどき, たまに → now and then.

Vたことがあります N5

Have done …: an experience.

Use it when:

  • Verb た-form + ことがあります
  • An experience in your life, usually from some time ago
  • Negative: 〜たことがありません (have never)
  1. I have climbed Mt. Fuji.
  2. I have never eaten natto, not even once.

Vることがあります N5

Sometimes …: frequency.

Use it when:

  • Verb dictionary form / ない-form + ことがあります
  • Something that is not frequent but happens now and then
  • Often goes with ときどき and たまに
  1. When I am busy, I sometimes don't eat lunch.
  2. This road is sometimes crowded in the morning.

Same situation, different meaning

I have been late to work (once, at some time).
I am sometimes late to work.

た: something that happened in the past. る: something that can repeat in the present.

Common mistakes

  • Wrong昨日、すしを食べたことがあります。

    Right昨日、すしを食べました。

    たことがある does not go with a specific time such as 昨日. To tell what happened, use the plain past.

  • Wrongときどき、友達と映画を見たことがあります。

    Rightときどき、友達と映画を見ることがあります。

    ときどき (sometimes) → ることがある.

Ask yourself before choosing

  1. Are you telling an experience, “have / have never”? → たことがある.
  2. Are you talking about frequency, “sometimes”? → ることがある.
  3. Does the sentence have 昨日 or 先週? → use only the plain past.

Practice

「子どものころ、北海道に住んだ__。」
  1. ことがあります
  2. ことにします
  3. ところです
  4. ばかりです
Show the answer and explanation
ことがあります
An experience from childhood → たことがあります.
「たまに、朝ご飯を食べない__。」
  1. ことがありました
  2. ことがあります
  3. ことになります
  4. ところです
Show the answer and explanation
ことがあります
たまに means once in a while → ることがあります.

Where this page comes from

The patterns are selected and graded to match the JLPT N5〜N1 range. The explanations and example sentences are written by Bunpo Dojo and are not copied from any textbook. If you find a mistake, please write to juxingdaochang@foxmail.com.